Homemade Seafood Boil Seasoning Recipe

We recently shared a full-blown seafood boil recipe packed with crab, clams, lobster, mussels, and shrimp, all simmered in a broth seasoned with classic Old Bay. It was delicious, no doubt.

But if you’re ready to take things up a notch, it’s time to break out of the jar and mix up your own bold seafood boil seasoning from scratch.

This homemade blend leans into Cajun flavors with a warm backbone of paprika, garlic, and thyme, plus enough kick to stand up to a whole pot of shellfish. And the best part? You get to control the salt, the heat, and the overall vibe. Want it spicier? Milder? Smokier? It’s all up to you.

Scroll down to find the “Jump to Recipe” button and Table of Contents if you’re ready to dive straight into the mixing bowl. Whether you’re boiling, butter-basting, or dry-rubbing your seafood, this seasoning brings the flavor every time.

Just like we used to do back on coastal cookout nights, spices everywhere, butter melting, and someone always saying, “Wait, what did you put in that? It’s amazing.”

Table of Contents

Ingredients You’ll Need

Making your own seafood boil seasoning is surprisingly simple, and chances are, you’ve already got most of these spices in your pantry. This blend hits all the right notes: smoky, spicy, earthy, and aromatic. Here’s what you’ll need:

• Paprika – Use regular for a classic base or smoked for deeper flavor.
• Cayenne Pepper – Adds heat; start small if you’re spice-sensitive.
• Garlic Powder – A must for bold, savory depth.
• Onion Powder – Rounds out the garlic and adds warmth.
• Dried Thyme – Earthy and herbaceous, balances the spice.
• Dried Oregano – Lends a slightly bitter edge that complements seafood.
• Black Pepper – Brings a sharp bite.
• White Pepper – Adds complexity and heat without the black specks.
• Crushed Red Pepper Flakes – For those fiery little jolts in every bite.
• Celery Seed – Brings that Old Bay vibe without overpowering.
• Salt – Go with kosher or sea salt for best texture and control.

Optional Add-Ins:

• Sugar – Just a pinch helps mellow the heat and bring balance.
• Mustard Powder – Bright and tangy, like in Old Bay.
• Lemon Zest – Adds a citrusy lift that makes shellfish shine.

This blend is endlessly adjustable. Like it smoky? Add more smoked paprika. Want to tame the heat? Ease off the cayenne and flakes. Make it yours, just like we do with every pot we boil.

(Stick around, next we’ll show you exactly how to mix, scale, and store it like a pro.)

---

Instructions

Now it’s time to mix these ingredients to make a good seafood boil seasoning, and we will show you later in the article how to store it, so you can use it later if you want.

1. Measure and Combine the Spices

In a medium mixing bowl, add the following measured ingredients:

• 2 tablespoons paprika
• 1 tablespoon garlic powder
• 1 tablespoon onion powder
• 1 tablespoon dried thyme
• 1 tablespoon dried oregano
• 1 tablespoon black pepper
• 1 tablespoon white pepper
• 1 tablespoon crushed red pepper flakes
• 2 teaspoons cayenne pepper
• 1 tablespoon celery seed
• 1 tablespoon kosher salt

Optional Add-Ins:

• 1 teaspoon mustard powder
• 1 teaspoon sugar
• Zest from 1 lemon (air-dried before mixing)

Stir well using a whisk or fork until all the spices are evenly blended. Break up any clumps, especially in the paprika or garlic powder, for a smooth, consistent mix.

2. Scaling for a Crowd

Hosting a big boil? Simply multiply the base recipe. For example:

• Double batch for 4–6 people
• Triple or quadruple for 8–12+ guests

A general rule: you’ll want about ¼ cup of seasoning per gallon of boiling water (and you may want more for tossing afterward in butter or using as a rub).

3. Storing Your Seasoning

Transfer your mix to an airtight glass jar or spice container. Label it with the name and today’s date. Store in a cool, dark place, like a pantry or spice drawer, away from heat and light.

4. Shelf Life

When stored properly, your seafood boil seasoning will keep its bold flavor for up to 6 months. After that, it may lose potency, especially the garlic and herbs. Trust your nose, if it smells weak or flat, it’s time to mix a fresh batch.

A quick tip: whole spices last longer than ground, so if you have a grinder, consider starting with whole peppercorns or celery seed.

(Next up, we’ll show you exactly how to use this blend in water, butter, or as a rub! Check it out after the recipe card)

---

Print

---

How to Use This Seasoning

This homemade seafood boil seasoning isn’t just for boiling water (though it shines there). It’s a versatile blend that works its magic in three key ways, depending on how you’re cooking and serving your seafood.

1. In the Boiling Water

Use this method when you’re cooking shell-on seafood like shrimp, crab, lobster, clams, or crawfish.

• How much to use: Add ¼ cup of seasoning per gallon of water. For heavily seasoned boils, bump it up to ⅓ cup.
• Add the seasoning after the water comes to a boil and just before you add your seafood.
• For extra depth, toss in sliced lemon, garlic cloves, or halved onions along with the seasoning.

This method infuses the seafood while it cooks, especially if you give it a short soak after turning off the heat.

2. As a Dry Rub

This seasoning also doubles as a dry rub for grilled, baked, or broiled seafood. It’s especially great for:

• Shrimp skewers
• Salmon fillets
• Snapper, trout, or catfish

Lightly oil your seafood, sprinkle the seasoning generously, and let it sit for 15–30 minutes before cooking to let the flavors soak in.

3. In Cajun Butter Sauce

The same spice mix transforms into a bold post-boil sauce. Here’s how:

• Melt 1 stick (½ cup) of unsalted butter
• Stir in 1–2 tablespoons of the seasoning
• Optionally, add minced garlic and a splash of lemon juice
• Toss your just-boiled seafood in the butter to coat

No matter how you use it, this seasoning delivers bold, balanced flavor with every bite.

---

Cajun vs Creole vs Old Bay – What’s the Difference?

If you’ve ever stood in the spice aisle wondering whether to reach for Old Bay or Cajun seasoning, or confused Creole with either one, you’re not alone. These blends share some common roots, but they bring distinctly different flavor vibes to the boil.

Cajun Seasoning

Cajun blends are known for being spicy, herb-forward, and earthy. They usually include:

• Paprika (sometimes smoked)
• Garlic and onion powders
• Cayenne pepper
• Oregano, thyme, black pepper

This is the base inspiration for our homemade seafood boil seasoning. It brings a rustic heat and a bold, no-nonsense punch that stands up to robust shellfish flavors.

Creole Seasoning

Creole cuisine shares some DNA with Cajun, but it tends to be a bit more refined and balanced, with more emphasis on layered flavors rather than heat.

• Often includes bell pepper or tomato elements in the dish (though not usually in the seasoning)
• The spice mix is similar, but may be slightly sweeter or less intense
• May also feature celery salt or white pepper

In cooking, Creole recipes often lean toward saucy, tomato-rich preparations, while Cajun dishes keep it dry-spiced and fire-kissed.

Old Bay Seasoning

Old Bay is the most widely recognized commercial seafood seasoning, especially on the East Coast. It’s milder than Cajun and has a sweet-spicy-savory profile.

Key notes include:

• Celery salt (its signature flavor)
• Paprika and mustard powder
• A touch of clove, allspice, and sometimes ginger

Old Bay is iconic for steamed crab, shrimp cocktail, and potato dishes, but it doesn’t pack quite the bold heat that Cajun does.

Bottom Line: If Old Bay is your dependable classic, Cajun is your bold rebel, and Creole is your smooth-talking cousin with a tomato garden.

---

Seasoning Variations

One of the best things about making your own seafood boil seasoning? You’re in charge. Whether you’re cooking for spice lovers, salt-watchers, or smoky flavor fanatics, there’s a way to tweak this blend to fit your kitchen vibe.

Want It Spicier?

Dial up the heat with:

• Extra cayenne pepper (start with ½ tsp at a time)
• More crushed red pepper flakes
• A pinch of chipotle powder for heat with a smoky edge

Add Brightness

Seafood loves citrus. For a zesty lift:

• Add lemon zest (air-dried before mixing)
• Try dried citrus peel or citric acid if you want a longer shelf life

Make It Smoky

Swap out standard paprika for smoked paprika, or blend in:

• A pinch of chipotle powder
• Smoked sea salt (use in place of regular salt)

Go Low-Sodium

To reduce salt:

• Cut the salt amount in half (or omit it completely)
• Use your seasoning blend as a salt-free base, and season to taste during cooking

This spice mix is your blueprint, but no seafood boil seasoning recipe is complete without a little personalization. Taste, tweak, and test until it feels like your own.

---

Storage Tips

Once you’ve mixed your seafood boil seasoning, keeping it fresh is all about proper storage. Ground spices can lose their punch over time, especially if exposed to heat, light, or moisture, so here’s how to protect that bold flavor.

Use an Airtight Jar

Transfer the blend to a glass spice jar or mason jar with a tight-fitting lid. Avoid plastic if you can, it can absorb and alter flavors over time. If you’re making a big batch, wide-mouth jars make scooping easier.

Label It

Write the name and date right on the jar. A simple masking tape label works fine. This helps you track freshness and reminds you what’s inside that mystery mix six months from now.

Store in a Cool, Dark Place

Spice cabinets, drawers, or a pantry shelf away from the stove are ideal. Avoid storing it above the oven or next to a sunny window, heat and light break down the oils in spices and dull their flavor faster.

Shelf Life

For best flavor, use your homemade seafood boil seasoning within 6 months. It might last longer, but the intensity (especially from garlic, paprika, and dried herbs) fades with time.

Quick Test: If it doesn’t smell strong, it won’t taste strong. When in doubt, make a fresh batch. It takes less than five minutes.

---

FAQ

Can I use this for shrimp only?

Absolutely. This seafood boil seasoning works beautifully for shrimp, whether you’re boiling, grilling, or pan-searing. Just adjust the amount to match your heat preference.

What if I don’t have paprika or celery seed?

Paprika is a key base flavor, but you can substitute with chili powder or smoked paprika. If you’re out of celery seed, skip it or add a small pinch of fennel or coriander for a slightly herbal note.

Can I add this to melted butter?

Yes! Mix 1–2 tablespoons into melted butter for a bold, flavorful sauce. Great for tossing boiled seafood, dipping crab legs, or brushing over grilled fish.

Can I use it for non-seafood (e.g., chicken)?

Definitely. This seasoning also works on chicken, roasted veggies, fries, or even popcorn. Just go easy on the salt if your dish already includes salty components.

---

Final Thoughts

Making your own seafood boil seasoning isn’t just about bold flavor, it’s about freedom. You get to control the salt, the spice, the balance, and the cost. No more guessing what’s in the store-bought stuff or paying extra for a tiny tin. Just real ingredients, your way.

You may also like:
– Pesto Cream Sauce Recipe

So next time you’re planning a boil, skip the pre-mix and reach for your homemade jar. It’s a small step that makes a big difference, and your seafood will thank you.